Background
The possibility of intra-class cross-resistance may limit the
sequential use of drugs, but the extent of these phenomena has
yet to be defined particularly for protease inhibitors (PIs)
that show complicated and polymorphic mutational patterns.
Methods
We evaluated the PI cross-resistance in a cohort of HIV
patients. Drug resistance interpretation was based on the
Stanford University beta test that assigns determined scores for
each amino acid substitution (www.stanford.edu).
Results
Data from 246 patients were analyzed. Most of them were multi-PI
experienced (SQV 62%, RTV 55%, IDV 73%, NFV 71%, APV and LPV
3%). There was a direct correlation (Pearson test P < 0.01) for
all possible head to head comparisons of resistance scores.
However, we also observed a significant difference in the
proportion of strains resistant to each PI: 84% to NFV, 64% to
SQV, 56% to IDV or RTV, 51% to APV and 45% to LPV (P < 0.0001
for APV or LPV vs. other PIs). 22% and 34% of strains resistant
to SQV were still susceptible to APV and LPV, respectively.
Similarly, 11% and 21% of strains resistant to IDV and RTV were
still susceptible to APV or LPV and these values rose to 39% and
51% for NFV resistant strains. This last result was deeply
influenced by the 15% of strains showing resistance to NFV
mainly because of the presence of 30D/N mutation that were
invariably susceptible to both APV and LPV.
Conclusions
The increment of resistance to one PI is associated to a
progressive reduction of efficacy of all other drugs of this
class. This intra-class cross-resistance is however not absolute
and drugs such as APV and LPV can be effective on a quite large
proportion of viruses resistant to other PIs. This is
particularly true for viruses resistant to SQV and NFV. This
observation gives new insights on the possibility of PI
sequencing.